Put-in-Bay Rental Homes | The 3 Best Home Rentals Downtown!

Come and Experience

Photo of nightlife near Put-in-Bay Rental Homes




Savy Put-in-Bay Vacationers know the best rental homes on the island are located in the popular downtown area, within walking distance to Put-in-Bay’s most popular restaurants, shopping & nightlife! Explore these top picks for your family vacation on South Bass Island in Lake Erie!

The All Star Ohio House

One Of Put-in-Bays Most Popular Rental Homes

Sleeps Up To 22 Guests- All-Star Ohio House

Put-in-Bays Only Modern Downtown Home Rental!

The stylish All Star Ohio House Put-in-Bay Rental Homes feature six bedrooms and three bathrooms with an enormous living room & social area, a modern, well-equipped kitchen, and TWO awesome private decks that are ideal for people-watching or enjoying the Put-in-Bay experience!

The All Star Ohio House front deck peeks out over Loraine Ave, one of the most active Put-in-Bay walking streets! The expansive rear deck opens to a large secluded private patio with a large BBQ Grill, cornhole, and picnic tables and is themed with Ohio Sports Memorabilia. Be sure to Contact Us with ANY questions you may have!

Put-in-Bay Rental Homes…. Location Location Location!!!

Our modern rental homes eliminate the need for expensive and time-consuming island transportation! The All-Star Ohio House was recently voted one of the best places to stay on Lake Erie!

Enjoy gathering with your group for a cookout on the BBQ grill along with a modern, spacious kitchen! DirecTV and Wi-Fi to view or stream your favorite shows or sporting events!

Once you’ve settled in your Put-in-Bay Home Rental, you’re less than 300 feet from the island’s best restaurants, shopping, and of course, the vibrant nightlife! The beautiful Put-in-Bay Waterfront and marina district is just a little over a block away!

The All-Star Ohio House allows you the convenience of being just a short walk from attractions and is less than one block from the famous Blue Marlin Pool Bar, where guests enjoy VIP access. It’s known as the place to be and be seen at Put-in-Bay! Be sure to Visit Our FAQ page! To learn about Put-in-Bay!

Submit A Reservation Request Here
or call 833-742-2827


The Allstar Ohio House
Put-in-Bay Rental Homes Photo
Picture Of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes!
Picture of the All Star Ohio House rental homes at Put-in-Bay

Put-in-Bay Villas Rental Homes!


The Put-in-Bay Villa Rental Homes are the most sought-after vacation rental homes on Put-in-Bay. Visitors will enjoy all the comforts of home while on their Lake Erie Island vacation. The many benefits include much more space, individual private bedrooms, and a full-service kitchen.

Booking a vacation home rental is an excellent way to stay on Put-in-Bay for value and comfort! Put-in-Bay Villas, 8-person units, are located in the heart of downtown; no need for the costly and hard-to-find taxi to get back and forth! Many groups save hundreds of dollars over a weekend by not paying taxis at $4.00 per person each way all weekend!

Great savings on your vacation can be found by utilizing the great amenities. Put-in-Bay Villas can accommodate eight guests. The kitchen is fully equipped with all the necessary items to prepare and serve a light meal. Also, two enormous propane BBQ grills are provided for grilling up some delicious selections. After enjoying a delightful meal, step outside onto one of two outdoor decks featured in each unit to unwind.

 The living room features comfortable furnishings and a 55″ flat screen television with DirecTV service. Four bedrooms afford guests private rooms and greater flexibility in sleeping configurations. A large heated pool with a swim-up bar is located across the street along with the Blue Marlin Bar & Grill, the island’s most famous swim-up bar!

Unlike other home rentals on the island, you won’t need to stress about hauling your sheets, towels, pillows & Linens along with you as they’re all provided with daily maid service! Guest also enjoy on-site free parking, free hi-speed wi-fi, and discounted Put-in-Bay golf cart rentals at some of the lowest rates on the island! A continental breakfast is provided daily (excluding Saturdays & Sundays).

The Put-in-Bay Villas are an excellent choice for lodging while visiting Put-in-Bay. The room and flexibility that are offered are unparalleled to other options. Be sure to consider renting vacation rental homes when planning an island stay. Many wedding groups and receptions, birthday celebrations, anniversaries, and more have been commemorated at the Villas. With the Put-in-Bay Villas being so popular, dates fill fast, so book early! 

Submit A Reservation Request Here
or call 888-742-7829

Bay Lodging 2 Bedroom


The Bay Lodging 2 Bedroom Condo rentals are perfect for families and friends who wish to enjoy the privacy of separate bedrooms yet the creature comforts of a full-sized kitchen, living room, and a terrific location. Most units are ground floor, and the Bay Lodging Resort is the islands only resort hotel that permits pets!

Just two blocks from the main strip, the Bay Lodging Resort is close enough to walk to all the action yet quiet enough to enjoy a restful night of sleep after a night on the town. Golf Cart Rentals are welcome on sie with ample parking!

The Bay Lodging Resort is home to the island’s only indoor-outdoor swimming pool! The kids love the swim-thru passage that takes them from inside the building to the outside pool deck.  Adults will enjoy the island’s newest hot spot SJ’s Hideaway, where talented bartenders whip up your favorite beverage, and there’s always a game or three on the large-screen TVs.

Guests of the Bay Lodging Resort enjoy free high-speed wi-fi connections and large TVs with DirecTV access. A complimentary continental breakfast is included Monday Thru Friday! Be sure to check out our specials & discounts page for great vacation savings!


Submit A Reservation Request Here
or call 888-742-7829
Photo Of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes
Picture of Put-in-Bay Villas Rental Homes
Photo of Put-in-Bay Villas 8 person Villa
Photo of Put-in-Bay Villas
Picture of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes at Bay Lodging
Photo of Put-in-Bay Rentals Homes Bathroom at Bay Lodging
Photo Of Put-in-Bay Rental Homes Bedroom

Put-in-Bay Rental Homes

Rental homes are a great way to explore Put-in-Bay

Island without sacrificing the comforts of home.

From rooms suited to solo travelers and short visits to large, luxurious lodgings and amply-sized spaces that accommodate up to ten travelers, there’s a Put-in-Bay home rental to meet every need. You can rely on us to guide you thru everything you need to know about booking a Put-in-Bay Rental Home.

Put-in-Bay is brimming with attractions. From the busy, vibrant downtown core—home to the island’s best restaurants, liveliest bars, and a diverse shopping district—to the natural beauty of South Bass Island, the shores of Lake Erie, and a variety of fascinating monuments and museums & history, there’s something here for everyone. Take advantage of great rates and early booking today—Put-in-Bay attracts hundreds of thousands of visitors each year, and our accommodations are limited in number. Booking early is the key to securing the rental home that best meets your needs.

Put-in-Bay offers a wide variety of lodging options. Choose a cozy cottage near the woods at Bay Lodging or a new Villas at the Put-in-Bay Resort. Traveling with a big family or large group? Put-in-Bay has many places to stay, from generously sized condos to luxury villas. Expect clean accommodations, great amenities, and all the comforts of home. The best places to stay in Put-in-Bay are in close proximity to the island’s many attractions, from the downtown core to the beautiful shore.

Select lodgings offer Put-in-Bay golf cart rentals—the best way to get around the island! And even Put-in-Bay rental homes that are off the beaten path are never far from activity and excitement, providing the perfect place to refresh and recharge before—or after!—a night on the town. Guests are always close to the water, with a wide variety of fantastic restaurants and fascinating historical sites. Book your Put-in-Bay Hotel or Lake Erie vacation rental home today—save time and money, and get a great place to stay in Put-in-Bay at an unbeatable price!





For over 150 Years, Put-in-Bay has attracted friends and families with a neverending list of fun-filled things to do! Few places on earth offer so many varied activities in such a small island location. Many families return generation after generation annually to enjoy the jewel of the Lake Erie Islands!


Photo of The Perry Peace Memorial At Night
Photo of nightlife near Put-in-Bay Rental Homes
Photo of the Boardwalk Restaurant

What Is There To Do At Put-in-Bay?



Photo of the Clydesdales at Put-in-Bay

Put-in-Bay Events

There is always something going on at Put-in-Bay, with activities for young and old alike! Browse the events calendar and pick a fun family event!

Photo of the Boardwalk Restaurant

Put-in-Bay Restaurants

From the waterfront to poolside, fine dining to delivery, Put-in-Bay Restaurants offer many types of local and regional cuisines for your vacation dining pleasure!

Photo Of Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals

Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rental

At Put-in-Bay, Golf Carts are considered our principal method of transportation. Lean how and why to make a reservation for your family vacation today!